Pumpkin Pie Not From a Can

Pumpkin Pie Not From a Can | My Halal Kitchen

I could eat Pumpkin Pie any time of year. It just so happens that because pumpkins are seasonal in the fall here in the Midwest, I truly crave this exact type of pie at this exact time of the year. I love the smell of fresh pumpkin so I began to steam small pie pumpkins myself, also known as sugar pumpkins. I steamed about three already this fall. (You can find my recipe for steamed pumpkin puree here).

With the freshly steamed pumpkins I made smoothies, soups and of course, pumpkin pie. It’s healthy and nutritious and the smell of it takes me back to my youth, when I never tired of fresh pies made by nearly every single family member this time of year.

Some people say canned pumpkin is just as good as the fresh- it may be just fine, depending on how fresh the pumpkins were when they were steamed and whether or not they were grown with pesticides or other chemicals. I like to take matters into my own hands and get my own organic pumpkins and do the steaming myself- in a big tamale pot. You can use any large stock pot or Dutch oven. Have fun with it. Enjoy the smells and enjoy the flavors that reward you in the end with your very own homemade pie, with whipped cream on top, of course.

Homemade Pumpkin Spice Mix

Pumpkin Spice mixes are readily available at stores right now, but why not make a super fresh mix of your own? Use a coffee or spice grinder and grind up your own whole spices for the freshest seasoning to this very homemade pie recipe. What more could anyone ask for?

2 tablespoons ground cinnamon

1/8 teaspoon ground cloves

1 teaspoon ground allspice

1/2 teaspoon ground ginger

1/8 teaspoon grated nutmeg

Combine all ingredients and place in a jar with a tight-fitting lid. Remains fresh for several weeks.

Pumpkin Pie (Not From a Can)

Makes 2 pies

Special Equipment

stand mixer with paddle and wire whisk attachments

2 pie plates

2 baking sheets

pie crust covers or aluminum foil


1 pie pumpkin (makes about 5-1/2 to 6 cups fresh pumpkin puree)

1/2 cup sugar

1 tablespoon pumpkin spice mix

1/2 teaspoon no-alcohol vanilla extract

1/2 teaspoon salt


1 can evaporated milk

2 pre-made pie pastry dough circles

whipped cream


  1. Preheat oven to 400º.
  2. Follow recipe directions for my steamed pumpkin puree, allowing yourself enough time to let it cool before making the pie filling. Meanwhile, defrost the pre-made pie dough but keep it cold until it’s time to use.
  3. To a stand mixer, add the cooled pumpkin and sugar. Mix well using the wire whisk attachment. Add the spice mix, vanilla and salt. Mix again thoroughly.
  4. Remove the wire whisk and change to the paddle attachment. Add the eggs and condensed mil. Mix until they are completely combined into the pumpkin.
  5. Prepare each of the two pie plates by rolling out the defrosted and cold dough and place in the pie dish. Crimp the edges before filling each pie with the same amounts of filling.
  6. Place each pie on its own baking sheet, in the center of each rack in the heated oven. Bake for 15 minutes.
  7. Reduce heat to 350º and bake for an additional 30 minutes, or until pies are firm in the center. Turn off heat, open the oven door and allow to cool completely.
  8. Cut and serve with whipped cream on top. I would say this part is optional, but I think whipped cream is obligatory!

Bismillah and Bon Appetít!

This post may contain affiliate links. If you use these links to buy something I may earn a commission. MyHalalKitchen.com is a participant in the Amazon Services, LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. Please see my affiliates disclosure page for more detailed information about the companies with who I am affiliated. 

Related Articles


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  1. I LOVE from scratch pumpkin pie…nothing comes close!! Whoever thinks that from the can is the same thing is clueless 🙂 However, I don’t think I’ve ever known anyone that didn’t notice the difference between fresh and from scratch…and didn’t convert to from scratch once introduced to from scratch. From the can is no where as good as from scratch…and I dare anyone to say it is! Hehe

  2. Hey,
    I have had your pumpkin pie a while back. And had been wanting to tell you …..I loved it. Pumpkin pie is my most favorite pie and yours was just perfect. It was the right amount of sweet …although I can take it even less sweater and it was perfectly buttery. Thanks for sharing it!

  3. Salam, in the ingredients section it says you need 1 teaspoon ground allspice.
    What is ‘allspice’? JazakAllah khair

      1. Now I know! Thanks! I always wonder what allspice is either… I first thought it was a mix of all kinds of spice, LOL~

  4. Does this recipe use evaporated or condensed milk? In the ingredients it lists evaporated milk but in the directions you mention condensed.

    Thank You

Get the latest updates & lots of FREE goodies!

Subscribe To My Quick Bites Newsletter

By signing up, you’ll be notified when new recipes and other tasty treats are cooked up in my kitchen!