At The Martha Stewart Show 1st Annual Pie Bake-Off


It’s been several weeks since I’ve returned from New York City and the Martha Stewart Pie Show. I still feel elated by just being there, as it was truly one of the most exciting things a foodie like myself could ever be invited to attend.  

The moment I received the invitation to bring my own homemade pie to be judged by some of the best pastry chefs in New York, I was excited and nervous, to say the least. What kind of pie should I make? What kind of pie would withstand a 13-hour + car ride? How would I protect the pie while in the car? What ingredients should I use so the pie wouldn’t have to be refrigerated? So many questions to answer, and all I could think about was the thrill and nerve-racking idea of being at the studio where Martha would appear to tape her show that day. What if my pie was chosen? “I would probably faint”, I thought to myself.

apple pie taken to martha show  I decided on a traditional apple pie with my own special & unique filling and a double pate brisee (butter crust).

The night before the show, we arrived at Chelsea Studios in New York City to scope out the place and find out where we needed to go in the morning since we commuted from our hotel in Queens.  I’ve never been happier to arrive in a city, having such purpose and a raison d’être.

The morning of the show we arrived early—as did just about everyone else- pie in tow. Some tucked theirs into Longaberger baskets with pretty cloth napkins; others cleverly packaged their pies in cardboard pizza boxes. Mine, on the other hand, were brought in durable plastic Crate & Barrel pie tows, then topped with aluminum foil, just the way the Martha crew ordered. 

Martha Studios Sign

Soon after, the crew arrived with stainless steel carts to collect our entrance ticket: the homemade pie. I handed it over as if I was handing over a child for adoption, reluctant, but believing it was for a good cause, that the pie would have a better life in the hands of the Martha taste testers—and hopefully win. It would be well worth the sacrifice.

Without our pies, women began asking each other what kind of pies were brought, in a definitely competitive tone. One woman in the bathroom line ahead of me even turned around to asked what I brought, but was more interested in telling me the exact name of her unique pie. She ended up talking to Martha on the show, describing the contents of her pie.

Martha Pic at Martha Show

In the pre-production room, we were able to sit down and watch Martha shows on small plasma tvs or even buy Martha Show products while we waited for directions about what to do next. While waiting, Joey stood right in front of us and came to our side of the room to fire up the crowd and give us a strict instructions: no gum chewing, no getting out our seats during taping, all items should be under the chairs & be quiet during taping. No pictures or videos, either. Next thing you know, he excitedly addresses one of the audience members, supposedly famous (I had no idea who she was)- Marjorie Johnson– sitting two rows behind me. Little did I realize at this point that she would be going home with the coveted blue-ribbon prize. Did any of us have a chance to win? Have you seen how many blue ribbons this woman has won?

marthas magazines

martha show productionmartha show production

After being directed into the actual studio where the taping takes place, it’s easy to see that this show is quite a production- very well-organized, an absolutely beautiful set, and much thought to make it exciting and fun for the audience members, as well.

I tried to scope out my pie as I walked into the studio. I think I saw it. Maybe. There were a lot of apple pies on the long pie-tasting table. I think I saw it on the tvs that were placed in front of our seats. I even think one of the judges, Sarah Carey of Everyday Food,  nodded her head with a mouthful of my pie to say, “Yumm, that’s good.”

Ok, maybe it was wishful thinking. But I know the pie was tasty. It just had to be. Think positive. Always. Right?

pie judges at the martha show

the winning pie and baker with the Martha Show crew

In the end, Marjorie Johnson did win Martha’s 1st Annual Pie Bake-Off. I’m glad someone with her amount of baking experience was the winner. I’m sure I can learn a thing or two about baking from her. After all, pie crust always has room for perfection…

This post may contain affiliate links. If you use these links to buy something I may earn a commission. MyHalalKitchen.com is a participant in the Amazon Services, LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. Please see my affiliates disclosure page for more detailed information about the companies with who I am affiliated. 

Related Articles


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  1. Salaam Yvonne,

    I loved reading about your experience. MashaAllah it sounds like you had an awesome time. What’s the next episode you’ll be attending?? I say get that shrimp recipe up for a contest… mmmm how delicious!

    Take Care,

  2. As’salamualaykum!
    Yayyyyy Yvonne well chuffed for you. Prime time telly exposure with the infamous Martha Stewart, go’on sister!
    What a crappy shame your pie didn’t win! As you say, the rightful experienced woman did, so kudos to all. It’s the taking part that…

    Is there a link to the recipe for this pie or is it top secret?
    Looking forward to all your adventures, love this kitchen, feels like home.

    1. wa’alaikum as salaam and thanks to all of you sisters for your lovely comments. It’s so encouraging, especially coming from all of you, masha’allah. Insha’allah I WILL be publishing the pie recipe in a few days. I tested several recipes for the Martha Show so my notes are all over the place!

  3. assalamu alaykum,

    Subhanallah, I just really loved this post. I have to admit, though I love the tips and recipes you provide, I’m not really a huge food enthusiast. Still, this particular post really packed a punch because of the emotion that came through. I especially loved how you compared handing over your pie to a mother handing over her child for adoption. Priceless!


Get the latest updates & lots of FREE goodies!

Subscribe To My Quick Bites Newsletter

By signing up, you’ll be notified when new recipes and other tasty treats are cooked up in my kitchen!